White to move: find the best move... click the ? for the solutionBlack to move: find the best move... click the ? for the solution
Номер этюда: 90711
Комментарии 5
And here presumably the same joker gave four points. The study has a nice (partially anticipated) final and some good moves, but not more and the intro is terrible. (1,5 points)
It is a partial, not a full anticipation, of course, as a I wrote above. My main problem is with the introduction. There is a lot of non-thematic material, captures and exchanges. Most people who compose and evaluate studies find that these features, when they occur together, devalue a study considerably.
3. Rxc6 Kxc6 is an exchange. c6, c7 and a2 are technical pawns that are captured without having a clear function in the design of the study. The initial position is also too messy.
Ask Martin Minski all your questions about composition technique. He is Grandmaster, not me. But I have no doubt that he will have the same opinion in this particular case.
And here presumably the same joker gave four points. The study has a nice (partially anticipated) final and some good moves, but not more and the intro is terrible. (1,5 points)
Show anticipation if you found it. Explain why you think the introduction is terrible.
(found by S. Didukh)
It is a partial, not a full anticipation, of course, as a I wrote above. My main problem is with the introduction. There is a lot of non-thematic material, captures and exchanges. Most people who compose and evaluate studies find that these features, when they occur together, devalue a study considerably.
Please read carefully the annotations of the judge. There is no exchange in the introduction and all the captures are forced by sacrifices.
3. Rxc6 Kxc6 is an exchange. c6, c7 and a2 are technical pawns that are captured without having a clear function in the design of the study. The initial position is also too messy.
Ask Martin Minski all your questions about composition technique. He is Grandmaster, not me. But I have no doubt that he will have the same opinion in this particular case.